Appeal Ruling of the Speaker
84 YEA and 48 Nay
Date: 03/05/2009
Those who voted in the affirmative were:
| Anzelc | | Atkins | | Benson | | Bigham | | Bly | |
| Brown | | Brynaert | | Carlson | | Champion | | Clark | |
| Davnie | | Dittrich | | Doty | | Eken | | Falk | |
| Faust | | Fritz | | Gardner | | Gottwalt | | Greiling | |
| Hansen | | Hausman | | Haws | | Hayden | | Hilstrom | |
| Hilty | | Hornstein | | Hortman | | Hosch | | Huntley | |
| Jackson | | Johnson | | Juhnke | | Kahn | | Kalin | |
| Kath | | Kelliher | | Knuth | | Koenen | | Laine | |
| Lenczewski | | Lesch | | Liebling | | Lieder | | Lillie | |
| Loeffler | | Mahoney | | Mariani | | Marquart | | Masin | |
| Morgan | | Morrow | | Mullery | | Murphy, E. | | Murphy, M. | |
| Nelson | | Newton | | Norton | | Obermueller | | Olin | |
| Otremba | | Paymar | | Pelowski | | Persell | | Peterson | |
| Poppe | | Reinert | | Rukavina | | Ruud | | Sailer | |
| Scalze | | Sertich | | Simon | | Slawik | | Slocum | |
| Solberg | | Swails | | Thao | | Thissen | | Tillberry | |
| Wagenius | | Ward | | Welti | | Winkler |
|
Those who voted in the negative were:
| Abeler | | Anderson, B. | | Anderson, P. | | Anderson, S. | | Beard | |
| Brod | | Buesgens | | Bunn | | Cornish | | Davids | |
| Dettmer | | Dill | | Doepke | | Downey | | Drazkowski | |
| Eastlund | | Emmer | | Garofalo | | Gunther | | Hackbarth | |
| Hamilton | | Holberg | | Hoppe | | Howes | | Kelly | |
| Kiffmeyer | | Kohls | | Lanning | | Loon | | Mack | |
| Magnus | | McFarlane | | McNamara | | Murdock | | Nornes | |
| Peppin | | Rosenthal | | Sanders | | Scott | | Seifert | |
| Severson | | Shimanski | | Smith | | Sterner | | Torkelson | |
| Urdahl | | Westrom | | Zellers |
|