Skip to main content Skip to office menu Skip to footer
Capital IconMinnesota Legislature

Legislative News and Views - Rep. Steve Elkins (DFL)

Back to profile

Legislative Update - Medicare Changes

Monday, November 16, 2026

Dear Neighbors,

Now that the election has passed, I can resume my periodic email bulletins from the Capitol. I’m excited to get back to work for our wonderful community!

I’ll have more to say about the upcoming session soon, but I want to devote this bulletin to the subject of Medicare open enrollment, which is a hot topic for every senior right now as the open enrollment window closes on December 7th.

Medicare Open Enrollment

The turmoil in the Minnesota Medicare market this year is exceptional. We haven’t seen anything like this year since the federal government eliminated most Medicare “Cost Plans” in 2019, the year that I became eligible. The reasons for this year’s upheaval bear some explanation.

Basic Medicare Primer

The basic Medicare options are “Traditional Medicare” (with or without a Medicare Supplemental plan add-on, a.k.a. “Medigap”) and Medicare Advantage.

  • Traditional Medicare without a Medigap plan only covers about 80% of your medical care and doesn’t cover drugs, dental, vision or hearing aids.
  • Traditional Medicare with a Medigap plan from a private insurance company will plug some or all the remaining 20% of your medical care, depending on the supplemental plan that you choose, but it still doesn’t cover your drugs, dental, vision or hearing aids.
  • If you want drug (Medicare Part D) or dental coverage with Traditional Medicare you must purchase separate policies.
  • Medicare Advantage (Medicare Part C) plans are offered by private insurance companies and cover medical, drugs (almost always), dental (usually), vision (sometimes), hearing aids (sometimes) and sometimes even cover gym memberships and over-the-counter drugs.

Both Traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans are subsidized by the federal government through the Medicare deductions that were taken from our paychecks during our working years. Medicare Advantage plans have been able to offer a richer set of benefits because Congress has directed higher subsidies to those plans and because some of the private insurers (primarily the private for-profit insurers) have been gaming the system by using various techniques to earn risk-based bonuses by making their members look sicker.

The primary advantage of Traditional Medicare plus a Medigap plan has been that you can buy a Medigap plan that covers 100% of your medical expenses, while Medicare Advantage plans may have deductibles and co-pays that can leave you on the hook for up to several thousand dollars of out-of-pocket costs in a bad health year.

A Medigap plan that covers 100% of your medical costs can cost $4,500 to $5,500 per year in premiums alone (plus the cost of drug, dental and vison coverage), while the premiums for a Medicare Advantage plan can range from $0 to $1,200 a year.

Just about all doctors participate in Traditional Medicare, while some Medicare Advantage plans may limit the doctors you can see, though about 90% of Minnesota health care practices are “in network” for Medicare Advantage plans from non-profit carriers like Blue Cross, Medica and Health Partners. For-profit insurance carriers like United Healthcare or Humana are more likely to exclude expensive providers from their networks.

Thus, it has been my observation that relatively healthy people tend to choose low-premium Medicare Advantage plans, while people who have expensive chronic medical conditions tend to buy expensive Medigap plans.

A couple of caveats:

If you have a Medicare Advantage plan, you cannot just switch to a Medigap plan when you become sick – you must go through “medical underwriting” and can be turned down for “pre-existing conditions.” However, if your Medicare Advantage plan is cancelled, then you have the right to switch to a Medigap plan without medical underwriting– and that’s happening a lot this year!

There is some evidence that claims denials and prior authorization denials are higher for large national for-profit insurers than they are for non-profit insurers. I passed a bill last session that will require all insurers to report their claim denials to the MN Department of Health so that you will be able to compare claim denial rates next year. Some hospital systems do not accept insurance from some insurance companies for this reason.

The 2026 Marketplace

So, what the hell is going on with the Medicare marketplace, this year? (especially the Medicare Advantage marketplace)

  • First, the federal government is reducing the rate of increase in plan subsidies to the Medicare Advantage carriers to below medical cost inflation.
  • Second, the federal government is cracking down on insurance carriers that have been boosting their subsidies by playing games that make their members look sicker.
  • Third, as Baby Boomers age towards our 80s, we incur more medical claims.
  • Fourth, hospital systems and drug companies have been increasing their prices more rapidly than the general rate of inflation.
  • Fifth, usage of expensive medications like GLP-1 weight loss drugs is increasing rapidly.
  • Sixth, the demise of UCare, which went bankrupt at the end of 2025, and the withdrawal of Humana from the market left many patients adrift and made it much more difficult for the remaining carriers to estimate their risk exposure from the new patients that they would be taking on from those carriers.
  • Seventh, because health plans are limited in the amount by which they can increase plan rates or remove plan benefits from one year to the next by federal law, they are discontinuing money-losing plans to cut their losses and creating new replacement plans, but only in areas of the state where they feel that they can at least break even with new plans.

Minnesota’s non-profit insurance companies (which, collectively, have about 90% of the Minnesota Medicare market) lost $486 million in 2024 and $598 million in 2025 on their Medicare plans. UCare, alone, lost $267 million in 2024 and $263 million in 2025 which, when combined with their similar losses in the Medicaid market, put them out of business. The surviving carriers just can’t keep bearing losses of this magnitude.

Recommendations

My number one piece of advice to any Medicare member, whether your plan is being cancelled or not, is to shop for a new plan on the Medicare.gov website every year! It’s easy to set up an account and the website gets better every year. You will be prompted to list the drugs that you’re taking and the doctors you see and the site will show you the total cost of insurance (premiums plus drug costs) for each plan and will tell you whether or not your doctors are in-network for each plan. You can rank the plans by cost and/or Medicare Star rating.

Another resource is Minnesota Aging Pathways, which will provide free guidance by phone or in-person by appointment.

You might be able to obtain assistance from a healthcare broker/advisor like

But some insurers are not paying broker commissions this year, so this kind of help is getting harder to find.

My wife and I are relatively healthy and so we have always chosen a Medicare Advantage plan. We have never had to pay a monthly premium (beyond the “Part B” premium that is deducted from every senior’s Social Security check). This will be our 9th year on Medicare and we have switched insurance carriers every two years among Medica, Blue Cross and Health Partners to get the best deal. They’ve all been OK – we’ve never had a denied claim or prior authorization and all our providers have been in-network. The Medicare Advantage plan that we’ve chosen for 2027 still has a $0 monthly premium, but it no longer covers glasses, hearing aids or over the counter drugs. (I got new glasses this year and we got hearing aids in 2025.) The out-of-pocket maximums are much higher, but my annual out-of-pocket expenses (mostly co-pays) have been in the range of $80 to $500 per year, which is way less than I would have paid in premiums for a Medigap plan. All our doctors are in-network and all our drugs are covered so it is still possible to find good options here in Hennepin County on Medicare.gov.

Keep in Touch

Don’t hesitate to reach out if I can provide any assistance. Please follow me on my Facebook page for further updates and invite your friends and family to do so as well. 

Thanks for the honor of representing you at the Capitol. 

Sincerely, 

Steve Elkins
Representative, District 50B
Minnesota House of Representatives
rep.steve.elkins@house.mn.gov